Entry tags:
The Man-o-sphere
I've been musing a bit about the man-o-sphere lately. I'm making this public because I think that this is worth a discussion.
The man-o-sphere has been capturing many young men these days, and after reading many ideas about that, I'm left with one conclusion: the man-o-sphere is attracting young men because they correctly identify the problems that young men face and they legitimize those problems.
There's lots to unpack, so let's start by not unpacking.
If we are to reach these young men, to pull them in a better direction, then we have to begin by recognizing their problems and legitimizing those problems. It's that simple, and like all simple things, is far more complex than it looks.
Here's where you ask some very good and pointed questions, and they are legitimate and important questions, but here is also where you need to stop and ask, "What is my goal here?"
What is my goal?
My goal, because I'm the person writing this, is to reach out to the disaffected young men, giving them some avenue other than the man-o-sphere. That's more important creating a perfect approach. I'd rather pull as many men out, before they get there, while it's easy, than later, when it's harder and more difficult to reach them.
So, what exactly is the issue? The issue is promises. I got all those promises when I was a young man, both over and implied, when I was a young man. All those promises said that I would come out on top and have all the girls. Instead, I didn't get that life. I had to revise who I was and how I approached my relationships, and did this multiple times.
These promises and dreams are fed into young men by the media, by stories written to cater to them, and so being so digestable, they take in those stories.
There's nothing special or unique about this. Women do the same with their own stories, and they face similar challenges. This is our gender modeling, how we come to understand ourselves as our genders in our society. However, we are not perfect embodiments of this gender modeling, so past a point, we each go our own way, revising and rediscovering our gender as we go.
This arena, where things are bursting apart, seems most prominent between 18 and 28, right in the turmoil years that we see. Taking our stories into the real world, our suppositions meet reality.
It should be no surprise that there's lots of emotion running about here, as there should be. It's appropriate to see disappointment, frustration, anger, annoyance, irritation, bitterness, doubts, uncertainties, and desires. These are natural and appropriate emotions that take time and effort to work through.
The dating world is an especially complicated machine, and it's lack of safety equipment guarantees that somebody's always going to get chewed up and spit out, men and women equally. If Reddit has taught me anything, it's that no gender has a lock on shitty behavior.
With all that, it's easy to wind up in a bad place, and there's no easy way out. A bit of cheer and optimism doesn't cut it. The solution is working on ourselves as people and hoping that we get lucky. There's no glory in that.
The man-o-sphere promises that easy out, the firm direction, those simple things that you can do that will matter, and that will make you matter. The man-o-sphere is successful because they offer the actionable, the implementable, and the achievable. They won't just give you directions, they'll help you feel manly, not just be manly.
They offer emotional crack, and that's genuinely hard to counter.
So we also have a second issue with the man-o-sphere, the exit plan. How do we extract people from that crack, that addiction?
I'll give you one proposition: victim blaming doesn't work. Those who are part of the man-o-sphere are mostly victims of it's shysters, being used for their money, and in exchange, they're further divided from all their support systems.
I wish that I could offer so easy way to fix all this, but I can't. All that I can do, I hope, is offer somewhere to begin.
The man-o-sphere has been capturing many young men these days, and after reading many ideas about that, I'm left with one conclusion: the man-o-sphere is attracting young men because they correctly identify the problems that young men face and they legitimize those problems.
There's lots to unpack, so let's start by not unpacking.
If we are to reach these young men, to pull them in a better direction, then we have to begin by recognizing their problems and legitimizing those problems. It's that simple, and like all simple things, is far more complex than it looks.
Here's where you ask some very good and pointed questions, and they are legitimate and important questions, but here is also where you need to stop and ask, "What is my goal here?"
What is my goal?
My goal, because I'm the person writing this, is to reach out to the disaffected young men, giving them some avenue other than the man-o-sphere. That's more important creating a perfect approach. I'd rather pull as many men out, before they get there, while it's easy, than later, when it's harder and more difficult to reach them.
So, what exactly is the issue? The issue is promises. I got all those promises when I was a young man, both over and implied, when I was a young man. All those promises said that I would come out on top and have all the girls. Instead, I didn't get that life. I had to revise who I was and how I approached my relationships, and did this multiple times.
These promises and dreams are fed into young men by the media, by stories written to cater to them, and so being so digestable, they take in those stories.
There's nothing special or unique about this. Women do the same with their own stories, and they face similar challenges. This is our gender modeling, how we come to understand ourselves as our genders in our society. However, we are not perfect embodiments of this gender modeling, so past a point, we each go our own way, revising and rediscovering our gender as we go.
This arena, where things are bursting apart, seems most prominent between 18 and 28, right in the turmoil years that we see. Taking our stories into the real world, our suppositions meet reality.
It should be no surprise that there's lots of emotion running about here, as there should be. It's appropriate to see disappointment, frustration, anger, annoyance, irritation, bitterness, doubts, uncertainties, and desires. These are natural and appropriate emotions that take time and effort to work through.
The dating world is an especially complicated machine, and it's lack of safety equipment guarantees that somebody's always going to get chewed up and spit out, men and women equally. If Reddit has taught me anything, it's that no gender has a lock on shitty behavior.
With all that, it's easy to wind up in a bad place, and there's no easy way out. A bit of cheer and optimism doesn't cut it. The solution is working on ourselves as people and hoping that we get lucky. There's no glory in that.
The man-o-sphere promises that easy out, the firm direction, those simple things that you can do that will matter, and that will make you matter. The man-o-sphere is successful because they offer the actionable, the implementable, and the achievable. They won't just give you directions, they'll help you feel manly, not just be manly.
They offer emotional crack, and that's genuinely hard to counter.
So we also have a second issue with the man-o-sphere, the exit plan. How do we extract people from that crack, that addiction?
I'll give you one proposition: victim blaming doesn't work. Those who are part of the man-o-sphere are mostly victims of it's shysters, being used for their money, and in exchange, they're further divided from all their support systems.
I wish that I could offer so easy way to fix all this, but I can't. All that I can do, I hope, is offer somewhere to begin.